{"name":"Whole Life Insurance Company Index","description":"Current Whole Life Insurance category consensus ranking published by Life Insurance Consensus Index.","url":"https://lifeinsuranceconsensusindex.com/whole-life-insurance","methodology":"https://lifeinsuranceconsensusindex.com/research-methodology","license":"https://lifeinsuranceconsensusindex.com/terms-of-use","snapshotId":"derived-whole-life-insurance","sourceFingerprint":"published-fit-review-evidence","calculatedAt":"2026-09-20T00:00:00.000Z","studyCount":16,"platformCount":7,"usableResponseCount":112,"entityCount":22,"rows":[{"rank":1,"entityId":"guardian-life","canonicalName":"Guardian Life","officialDomain":"guardianlife.com","entityType":"company","score":60.09,"studyAppearanceCount":13,"studyCoverageRate":81.25,"responseAppearances":85,"recommendationRate":75.89,"averageListedPosition":3.08,"bestPosition":1,"relevantResearchPath":"/whole-life-insurance/whole-life-insurance-for-high-early-cash-value/guardian-life"},{"rank":2,"entityId":"new-york-life","canonicalName":"New York Life","officialDomain":"newyorklife.com","entityType":"company","score":59.38,"studyAppearanceCount":15,"studyCoverageRate":93.75,"responseAppearances":87,"recommendationRate":77.68,"averageListedPosition":3.36,"bestPosition":1,"relevantResearchPath":"/whole-life-insurance/whole-life-insurance-for-estate-and-legacy-planning/new-york-life"},{"rank":3,"entityId":"massmutual","canonicalName":"MassMutual","officialDomain":"massmutual.com","entityType":"company","score":54.29,"studyAppearanceCount":12,"studyCoverageRate":75,"responseAppearances":68,"recommendationRate":60.71,"averageListedPosition":2.06,"bestPosition":1,"relevantResearchPath":"/whole-life-insurance/whole-life-insurance-for-dividends/massachusetts-mutual-life-insurance-company"},{"rank":4,"entityId":"penn-mutual-pennmutual-com","canonicalName":"Penn Mutual","officialDomain":"pennmutual.com","entityType":"company","score":50.98,"studyAppearanceCount":13,"studyCoverageRate":81.25,"responseAppearances":79,"recommendationRate":70.54,"averageListedPosition":3.77,"bestPosition":1,"relevantResearchPath":"/whole-life-insurance/whole-life-insurance-for-cash-value-accumulation/penn-mutual"},{"rank":5,"entityId":"northwestern-mutual","canonicalName":"Northwestern Mutual","officialDomain":"northwesternmutual.com","entityType":"company","score":50.27,"studyAppearanceCount":13,"studyCoverageRate":81.25,"responseAppearances":75,"recommendationRate":66.96,"averageListedPosition":3.49,"bestPosition":1,"relevantResearchPath":"/whole-life-insurance/whole-life-insurance-for-high-net-worth-individuals/northwestern-mutual"},{"rank":6,"entityId":"mutual-of-omaha","canonicalName":"Mutual of Omaha","officialDomain":"mutualofomaha.com","entityType":"company","score":17.77,"studyAppearanceCount":8,"studyCoverageRate":50,"responseAppearances":30,"recommendationRate":26.79,"averageListedPosition":4.37,"bestPosition":1,"relevantResearchPath":"/whole-life-insurance/whole-life-insurance-for-children/mutual-of-omaha"},{"rank":7,"entityId":"lafayette-life","canonicalName":"Lafayette Life","officialDomain":"lafayettelife.com","entityType":"company","score":16.7,"studyAppearanceCount":8,"studyCoverageRate":50,"responseAppearances":28,"recommendationRate":25,"averageListedPosition":4.32,"bestPosition":1,"relevantResearchPath":"/whole-life-insurance/whole-life-insurance-for-cash-value-accumulation/lafayette-life"},{"rank":8,"entityId":"state-farm","canonicalName":"State Farm","officialDomain":"statefarm.com","entityType":"company","score":12.86,"studyAppearanceCount":10,"studyCoverageRate":62.5,"responseAppearances":29,"recommendationRate":25.89,"averageListedPosition":6.03,"bestPosition":1,"relevantResearchPath":"/whole-life-insurance/20-pay-whole-life-insurance/state-farm"},{"rank":9,"entityId":"security-mutual-life-insurance","canonicalName":"Security Mutual Life Insurance","officialDomain":"securitymutual.com","entityType":"company","score":11.16,"studyAppearanceCount":2,"studyCoverageRate":12.5,"responseAppearances":14,"recommendationRate":12.5,"averageListedPosition":2.07,"bestPosition":1,"relevantResearchPath":"/whole-life-insurance/whole-life-insurance-for-business-owners/security-mutual-life-insurance"},{"rank":10,"entityId":"foresters-financial","canonicalName":"Foresters Financial","officialDomain":"foresters.com","entityType":"company","score":10.54,"studyAppearanceCount":8,"studyCoverageRate":50,"responseAppearances":23,"recommendationRate":20.54,"averageListedPosition":5.87,"bestPosition":2,"relevantResearchPath":"/whole-life-insurance/whole-life-insurance-for-children/foresters-financial"},{"rank":11,"entityId":"gerber-life","canonicalName":"Gerber Life","officialDomain":"gerberlife.com","entityType":"company","score":8.13,"studyAppearanceCount":3,"studyCoverageRate":18.75,"responseAppearances":12,"recommendationRate":10.71,"averageListedPosition":3.42,"bestPosition":1,"relevantResearchPath":"/whole-life-insurance/whole-life-insurance-for-children/gerber-life-insurance-company"},{"rank":12,"entityId":"ameritas","canonicalName":"Ameritas","officialDomain":"ameritas.com","entityType":"company","score":6.79,"studyAppearanceCount":7,"studyCoverageRate":43.75,"responseAppearances":17,"recommendationRate":15.18,"averageListedPosition":6.53,"bestPosition":4,"relevantResearchPath":"/whole-life-insurance/whole-life-insurance-with-paid-up-additions/ameritas-life-insurance-corp"},{"rank":13,"entityId":"pan-american-life","canonicalName":"Pan-American Life","officialDomain":"panamericanlife.com","entityType":"company","score":5.98,"studyAppearanceCount":4,"studyCoverageRate":25,"responseAppearances":12,"recommendationRate":10.71,"averageListedPosition":5.42,"bestPosition":3,"relevantResearchPath":"/whole-life-insurance/whole-life-insurance-for-cash-value-accumulation/pan-american-life"},{"rank":14,"entityId":"oneamerica","canonicalName":"OneAmerica","officialDomain":"oneamerica.com","entityType":"company","score":4.11,"studyAppearanceCount":5,"studyCoverageRate":31.25,"responseAppearances":14,"recommendationRate":12.5,"averageListedPosition":7.71,"bestPosition":3,"relevantResearchPath":"/whole-life-insurance/whole-life-insurance-for-dividends/oneamerica"},{"rank":15,"entityId":"protective","canonicalName":"Protective","officialDomain":"protective.com","entityType":"company","score":4.02,"studyAppearanceCount":2,"studyCoverageRate":12.5,"responseAppearances":7,"recommendationRate":6.25,"averageListedPosition":4.57,"bestPosition":1,"relevantResearchPath":"/whole-life-insurance/no-medical-exam-whole-life-insurance/protective-life"},{"rank":16,"entityId":"aarp","canonicalName":"AARP","officialDomain":"aarp.org","entityType":"company","score":3.57,"studyAppearanceCount":2,"studyCoverageRate":12.5,"responseAppearances":7,"recommendationRate":6.25,"averageListedPosition":5.29,"bestPosition":2,"relevantResearchPath":"/whole-life-insurance/no-medical-exam-whole-life-insurance/aarp"},{"rank":17,"entityId":"usaa","canonicalName":"USAA","officialDomain":"usaa.com","entityType":"company","score":3.3,"studyAppearanceCount":3,"studyCoverageRate":18.75,"responseAppearances":9,"recommendationRate":8.04,"averageListedPosition":6.89,"bestPosition":1,"relevantResearchPath":"/whole-life-insurance/whole-life-insurance-for-children/usaa"},{"rank":18,"entityId":"security-mutual-life","canonicalName":"Security Mutual Life","officialDomain":"smlny.com","entityType":"company","score":2.77,"studyAppearanceCount":2,"studyCoverageRate":12.5,"responseAppearances":5,"recommendationRate":4.46,"averageListedPosition":4.8,"bestPosition":1,"relevantResearchPath":"/whole-life-insurance/whole-life-insurance-for-cash-value-accumulation/security-mutual-life"},{"rank":19,"entityId":"transamerica-transamerica-com","canonicalName":"Transamerica","officialDomain":"transamerica.com","entityType":"company","score":2.59,"studyAppearanceCount":2,"studyCoverageRate":12.5,"responseAppearances":5,"recommendationRate":4.46,"averageListedPosition":5.2,"bestPosition":2,"relevantResearchPath":"/whole-life-insurance/simplified-issue-whole-life-insurance/transamerica"},{"rank":20,"entityId":"nationwide-nationwide-com","canonicalName":"Nationwide","officialDomain":"nationwide.com","entityType":"company","score":2.41,"studyAppearanceCount":2,"studyCoverageRate":12.5,"responseAppearances":5,"recommendationRate":4.46,"averageListedPosition":5.6,"bestPosition":1,"relevantResearchPath":"/whole-life-insurance/no-medical-exam-whole-life-insurance/nationwide"},{"rank":21,"entityId":"pacific-life-pacificlife-com","canonicalName":"Pacific Life","officialDomain":"pacificlife.com","entityType":"company","score":2.23,"studyAppearanceCount":3,"studyCoverageRate":18.75,"responseAppearances":6,"recommendationRate":5.36,"averageListedPosition":6.83,"bestPosition":5,"relevantResearchPath":"/whole-life-insurance/no-medical-exam-whole-life-insurance/pacific-life"},{"rank":22,"entityId":"national-life-group","canonicalName":"National Life Group","officialDomain":"nationallife.com","entityType":"company","score":1.96,"studyAppearanceCount":2,"studyCoverageRate":12.5,"responseAppearances":5,"recommendationRate":4.46,"averageListedPosition":6.6,"bestPosition":3,"relevantResearchPath":"/whole-life-insurance/whole-life-insurance-for-business-owners/national-life-group"}]}